Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab in Lancaster

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab in Lancaster
3.5 / 5
50 reviews

5555 Genesee St, Lancaster, NY 14086-9791, Lancaster

Overview

Cuisine
  • American
  • Bar
  • Seafood
Features
  • Seating
  • Waitstaff
  • Television
  • Serves Alcohol
  • Takeout
  • Wheelchair Accessible
Good for
  • Bar scene
  • Families witd children
  • Kids

Restaurant Hours

Monday

11:00 am

Wednesday

11:00 am

Friday

11:00 am

Sunday

11:00 am

Are reservations needed?

Holidays

Is this place open anymore? I’ve tried calling for hours and either it rings nonstop or I get a busy signal. I want to support local businesses, but I’m not having any luck.

Their open wear a mask to table and when getting up to lo eave

Is location easily handicap accessible, in that there are no stairs at one entrance and a folding walker would not be obstructive @ table?

Yes, there is handicap access in the rear door is at ground level or a slight step up actually for Walker it's definitely possible.

Was this place ever known as "The Rose Garden"?

No The Rose garden is now Angry Buffalo

Is there all you can eat crab legs?

No

Do you still have Lobster Dainties, and if so do you still sell them by the bag?

I remember seeing them on the menu this summer & ordered them last year. Don't remember by bag. Think by the order - 2 or 4?

Do you take credit cards?

No credit card cash only.atm on premises

How much is a fish dinner

Reasonable. Around $20

How much for a bag of clams for a party

I believe $40 i work there

do they take credit catds

What they said^^^

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
TT
Tary Touhey
google
05.15.2024
5/5

Great service , friendly staff , great atmosphere and the food is awesome !! What more can you ask for !!

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
JH
Janet H
google
10.24.2018
5/5

Amazing food. Fantastic people. The service there cannot be beat. The seafood is fresh and the prices are more than reasonable. They have specials Mondays and their happy hour is well worth the stop after work for a $2 drink. Not only have I never had a bad meal but I have met some regulars there that love the place and will tell you the same thing I'm telling you. The place is full of great people.

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
SW
Sandy Wilkolaski
google
10.19.2018
5/5

Love the food. Fish fry is great. Service fast, friendly. Prices reasonable.

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
JK
Jen Karaoke
google
09.01.2018
5/5

Went for take out today. It was my daughters birthday and unable to celebrate with family, we were on a mission for a good crab dinner. The owner went out of his way to be helpful, accommodating and personable. I couldn’t ask for more. The food was fresh, large portions and we were all very happy. Thank you for going out of your way to make it a special day for our family! The customer service was impeccable.

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
KC
Kathy Coleman
google
08.27.2018
4/5

Food was great, service was good, but beware of their cash only policy! A little confusing seeing we’re in the COVID pandemic 🤔

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
DP
DENNIS Petrie
google
08.21.2018
5/5

Great food And not expensive

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
nc
nick condrell
google
08.08.2018
4/5

Basic no frills seafood and steak. Great prices and friendly staff

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
TG
Tom Gluszak
google
07.16.2018
5/5

Waitress was rather rude and really didn't take that good care of our party of 4. The food was very good but really skimpy on the fries.

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
CR
Carrie Roundpoint
google
07.05.2018
4/5

Very good meal and service. I will definately go back.

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
PS
Peter Seiwert
google
05.19.2018
5/5

The prime rib was delicious and the fresh clams were so good and only $4.99 a dozen!

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
SM
Scott Myers
google
05.07.2018
5/5

All the food was great, everyone enjoyed their meal. Loved their clams casino. Sea scallops. Stuffed haddock with big delicious shrimp. Lobster Talis were great. Good beers on tap. All at great prices. Friendly service

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
SM
Shawn McCourt
google
05.07.2018
4/5

Delicious mussels, lobster dainties and oysters, but the peel and eat shrimp were drowned in Creole spice...best to go light, with a little Old Bay and drawn butter. Please stop with the spice, it ruins otherwise delicious shrimp.

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
PH
Pat Hachten
google
04.12.2018
5/5

Wow. This is the place to go to for seafood. Great food and great people.

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
ML
Marianne Lazzaro
google
04.12.2018
5/5

The best clams and lobsters

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
WH
Whitney Hannah
google
02.20.2018
5/5

Flew in from Florida and was meeting with family for a Christmas dinner, food was great! They had a huge party coming and had to move us after we ordered our drinks but they more than compensated and the service was great! We will definitely be going again.

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
MP
Maryann Provorse
google
01.27.2018
4/5

Had fries and large lobster dainties. I feel they were over done we always steamed ours but my fault for not asking how they prepared their dainties.

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
MD
Mike D.
google
01.26.2018
2/5

I've been here a few times previously during weekday a few years ago and the food was incredible. Went on Friday night & was very disappointed. Dozen steamed clams were very gritty & stringy. Needed a more thorough rinsing. We both ordered the ribeye med-rare (same as previous trips). My friend's was cooked unevenly. Outer portion was cooked correctly but middle was a different temp and very rare, almost cold. My ribeye was cooked more evenly but more towards medium. It was very fatty & it needed to be rendered more. It was a bit tough too. My jaw got a workout. Maybe it was an off night but disappointed after spending $90 (cash only).

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
BH
Brandy Henkel
google
11.13.2017
5/5

Wow what a gem!!!! If your craving sea food and dont to go down town this is your spot!!!👍👍👍

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
ml
mike l
google
10.07.2017
4/5

Prime rib sammy was good, ill be back

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
TN
Tracy Novoa
google
09.26.2017
5/5

Great place for very tasty and reasonably priced steak and seafood.

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
BW
Barb Woody
google
08.25.2017
4/5

Cash only so check your wallet before going here. No frills seafood and steak place. Very casual atmosphere, good food, friendly servers.

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
NC
N C
google
08.08.2017
5/5

I haven't been to Boston Hotel in years. Went with a few friends and completely enjoyed myself. Ordered steamed clams, Raw oysters, and captain jack oysters. Also had the wings and Red shrimp. Everything was so fresh and delish! Also great service from Amy the bartender and owner was social and sat at bar with us for a drink. I will definitely be back soon.

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
KS
Kevin Stablewski
google
07.23.2017
5/5

Food was very good. Highly recommend.

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
JL
Justin Lee
google
07.20.2017
5/5

Been going here for years and never had a bad experience. They had taken their Monday night clam specials away but recently brought it back. As of today, special is 3.99 for a dozen clams (raw or steamed) but I'd call ahead just to confirm. The special also used to start pretty late but now starts at 8PM. They also used to have snow crab cluster specials but that apparently went away since it got too expensive. It used to be packed with a line out the door, but when management took clam specials away for a while, ppl must've stopped going because when I went there just a few days ago, the place was a ghost town. Just a tiny bit of advertising and participation locally could bring the place back alive...

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
LK
L Kubik
google
06.17.2017
5/5

We come here every year for my son's birthday. It is always excellent. The service is wonderful. The food is delicious. Henry took the time to make sure we were happy several times during our evening. What a wonderful experience. Highly recommend.

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
CG
Cyd Green
google
05.13.2017
4/5

Great lobster dainty. Bacon on chicken bbq sandwich tasted a bit old

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
Larissa
google
04.23.2017
5/5

We order yesterday take out for my daughters birthday. The prime rib and the clams casino were perfect . We appreciate making a great birthday dinner even if we could not eat at the restaurant .thank you

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
KC
Keith Crabtree
google
04.09.2017
5/5

Great Sea food and great service

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
NYFred3
google
04.05.2017
5/5

Just had the beer battered fish. Superb, all sides were excellent. Wife had prime rib sandwich and she gave it 5 stars.Very friendly waitress.They do it right!

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
cf
chris frankhauser
google
03.15.2017
3/5

If you like o.k food and paper plates this is your spot

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
JA
Jolene A
google
03.03.2017
5/5

Looooooveeee this place.just widg they carried coke or Pepsi instead of rc.food is delish!!!!

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
bg
bob gibbons
google
02.26.2017
5/5

Food was delicious and waitress was so nice and helpful! 5 stars. I will go back

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
DB
Derek Bodziak
google
02.04.2017
4/5

Overall pretty happy... The crab legs weren't as meaty as I'm used to, which is the reason for 4 stars. I mentioned it to our waitress and she did offer another cluster for free. It is cash only here. Nothing fancy, paper plates ect ect.

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
JW
Jennifer Wantuck
google
02.01.2017
5/5

Our server was friendly and attentive. For a Wednesday night it wasn't overly busy for our 6p celebration for my parents' anniversary, but there still was plenty of patrons enjoying food and the bar. The food was good, fresh, and even slightly over portioned. Prices were extremely reasonable for the size of the meals. I ordered steamed clams and cajun style broiled haddock. Definitely willing to return to try another meal.

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
RT
Roberta Terbuska
google
11.19.2016
5/5

Great service and so good food. Worth every penny

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
JB
Jamey Bierzynski
google
11.15.2016
5/5

Never a bad meal! Absolutely delicious!But the service.. they make you feel rushed..

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
mc
michael czapski
google
11.09.2016
5/5

Had seafood plater ,some of the best food ever good service nice owner

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
MW
Mark Waltman
google
09.04.2016
5/5

We went for my birthday. The prime rib was quite moderately priced and was much better than many places I have tried. The salad was delicious with crispy lettuce, fresh tomatoes and ample dressing.I want to go back for the fish fry, which I heard is quite good and also moderately priced. The server was prompt and friendly. She was attentive to our needs but not overbearing. A couple of caveats, though. The dining room is small and at peak times gets full quick. Also, it's cash only.

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
JL
Jeff Levenson
google
07.23.2016
2/5

The clams where good, the stuffed haddock had alot to be desired

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
JS
Joanne Sonricker
google
07.08.2016
4/5

Food is wonderful. Steak and seafood especially the red shrimp is always cooked to perfection. Not to forget the French fries.

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
JP
Janie Philleo
google
07.03.2016
5/5

Have not visited this place and 20 years and came back and the food was just as good as it was back then. We had an awesome waitress or name was Renee. Will definitely be back soon. Thank you the wonderful food and wonderful service.

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
BK
Barbara Kaepernik
google
07.01.2016
5/5

Had a great burger and fries prepared exactly as requested!Fantastic music playlist.

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
dl
dean lewis
google
03.25.2016
4/5

Pretty good food for a decent price. Not a fancy place as they also have a bar side. They only accept cash so make sure you bring some but they also have an ATM inside for your convenience. Our server was great even helped my mother along as we were leaving and she is a little handicapped. I had the 14oz sirloin which she considered small (compared to some places their small is a 6oz size). Mom had the salmon and was just right according to her. Would definately be back next time we come through here.

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
JL
Joel Lee
google
03.09.2016
5/5

Love the place very down to earth service fanominal love the clams priced perfectly

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
DG
Darlene Geercken
google
03.04.2016
5/5

Excellent food and service. Great place! 😊

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
LR
Larry Ryckman
google
02.24.2016
5/5

Good food and good service and staff

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
DP
Dale Pawarski
google
02.21.2016
1/5

Amendment to first review. Been here for drinks and clams. Good prices of food and beverages. We usually have a decent time when meeting after work. However. ..... They do take orders for bags of clams and ...dainties. So I did. Called, Ordered, confirmed order, provided name and number... Go for pick. No order no clams no dainties and staff acts like I didn't order. Ok it happens I have a bunch of people to feed it was early in the day I'll figure it out. THIS WEEK SAME THING EXCEPT NOBODY WAS EVEN THERE, NO CALL, NO ONE ANSWERS can't leave a message! THEY TOLD ME WHEN TO PICK THEM UP! and it's not ok because again I didn't plan on having to drive around looking for the food that I ordered days prior.So, yea this place is not where you want order if you competent or Any service for that matter.I would suggest to everyone need a reliable restaurant to do your business with..... Keep looking.

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
SP
Sadé Preston
google
01.21.2016
5/5

Lobster Danties very good and the staff is friendly

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
SK
Sofa KingCool
google
01.12.2016
3/5

Got ribeye sandwich. .. very fatty meat..no flavor cold fries but cold beer and bring cash they don't accept any form of credit or debit card

Boston Hotel`s Steak & Crab
CB
Christian Bajak
google
01.10.2016
5/5

Excellent roast beef sandwich clams and the fries were outstanding..

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 17166816938

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!